Burba Dental featured image

New Lumineers Over Old

I had Lumineers placed quite a few years ago. I’ve never been happy with the color. My dentist knew I wanted whiter ones, but his tech guy told him it wasn’t possible to get them that white. In recent years, I think that has changed because I see a lot of people with really white teeth. I’ve been told that I can’t whiten them, but my dentist suggested we place new Lumineers on top of old Lumineers to make them look better. Have you heard about that being done before?

Madison

Dear Madison,

porcelain veneer being placed on a tooth

The one thing I agree with your dentist about is that using teeth whitening will not help with dingy Lumineers. Teeth whitening only works on natural tooth structure. Everything else he’s either done or suggested in regard to this case, I have serious concerns about.

Let’s start with the original color. Even several years ago, you would have been able to get your smile as white as you wanted. One thing you should know is that Lumineers is just one brand of porcelain veneers. This brand is highly marketed to inexperienced cosmetic dentists. However, most expert cosmetic dentists do not prefer that particular brand. The main reason for that is the company that owns Lumineers insist dentists use their lab, which isn’t known for its artistry or skill. This may be why that particular technician didn’t get them white the first time.

The second issue I have is his suggestion of new Lumineers over old. This is a really bad idea for a few reasons. First, it is just as difficult to place the Lumineers on top of the old ones as it is to just replace them.

Second, the Lumineers will not bond as well to porcelain as it will to your natural tooth structure. This puts it at risk of bonding failure. Finally, the chance of bonding failure doubles because both the new ones and the old ones are at risk.

Getting the Smile Makeover You Want

If you truly want a smile you will be proud of, you will need to go to a different dentist to get it. If you are happy with him as your general dentist, you can still use him in that capacity. Many patients have one dentist for general work and one for cosmetic work.

While there isn’t a recognized specialty in cosmetic dentistry, there is a way to ensure you have a skilled and artistic cosmetic dentist. I recommend that you see an AACD accredited cosmetic dentist. These dentists are in the top 1% of cosmetic dentists in the country. They can create a stunning smile for you. In fact, most of them even have a beautiful smile guarantee.

Don’t be surprised if whichever dentist you end up with suggests a different brand of porcelain veneers. They will know the strength and weaknesses of each and based on what type of smile you want, they will pick the brand whose strengths will give you the most benefit.

This blog is brought to you by Salem, MA Dentist Dr. Randall Burba.